We make the SemperScreen® permanent sink screen, and we own rental buildings in Southern California. We built the screen for our own kitchens before we ever sold one, and taking out garbage disposals is a job we know from the owner's side of the invoice.

Changing a garbage disposal to a regular drain is a one-visit job: shut off the power, take the disposal off its mount, fit a new drain in the sink opening, and rebuild the short run of pipe down to the trap. If a dishwasher drained into the disposal, it gets a new connection too. This guide covers whether you can legally remove a disposal, the parts you need, the steps in order, what you pay for, and what to put in the drain so the clogs don't follow you.

Is It Legal to Remove a Garbage Disposal?

In most places, yes. You can remove a garbage disposal and not replace it. The model plumbing codes set rules for how a disposal is installed when there is one. They don't require a kitchen to have one.

A few local rules do. The Estero Municipal Improvement District, which serves Foster City, California, requires a disposal in each residential unit, including each unit of a multi-family building. Check with your city or water district before you take one out. Our post on can a landlord remove a garbage disposal from a rental covers rules like this one.

What the code does care about is the open hole the disposal leaves behind. The International Plumbing Code requires a strainer, crossbar or other device to restrict the clear opening of a sink waste outlet (Section 422.2 in the 2018 through 2024 editions) [1]. So the sink can't be left with a bare flange. Something with a screen or crossbar has to go in. Our post on what to install after removing a garbage disposal compares the three options side by side.

Renting the property out? Removing a disposal from a rental also has rules about leases and turnover, covered in the same landlord post.

Do you need a plumber to remove a garbage disposal?

Not always. A handy owner with a free afternoon can do it. The disposal itself comes off with a quarter turn. The harder part is the rebuild: the new drain pipe has to line up with the trap and the wall outlet, every slip joint has to seal, and a dishwasher drain has to be reconnected the way your local code wants it.

We use a licensed plumber in three cases: a rental unit, any sink with a dishwasher, and a hardwired disposal (one wired straight into the wall rather than plugged into an outlet). In those cases the cost of getting it wrong is a leak inside a cabinet or a dishwasher that drains backwards.

Why People Are Making the Switch

Most people who take a disposal out are tired of the same three things: jams, clogs further down the line, and a motor that eventually needs replacing. A disposal grinds food smaller, but every ground piece still goes into your pipes. Grease rides along with it and coats the pipe wall, and the fine food sticks to that coating.

Homes on a septic system have a second reason. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency tells septic owners to "eliminate or limit the use of a garbage disposal," and says a tank that receives disposal waste will need to be pumped more often [2]. If that's your situation, read garbage disposals and septic systems next.

The third reason is composting. Scraps you scoop off a screen can go in a compost bin. Scraps you grind are gone down the pipe.

What Parts Are Needed

The materials required for a disposal-to-drain conversion are straightforward: a new sink strainer, drain tailpiece and P-trap assembly, along with plumber's putty, slip-joint pliers and a bucket to catch residual water. Lowe's walks through the same basics for the plumbing side of the job: power off at the breaker, a bucket under the P-trap, and plumber's putty to seal the drain [3].

Here is the biggest decision you need to make when choosing a new sink strainer: who is using the sink? Apartments.com states in its Rental Manager resource guide, "In theory, sink strainers prevent food scraps from going down the drain. In reality, not every tenant uses them consistently" [4]. That is human error that no training program fixes. If you are removing garbage disposals to have fewer clogs and fewer maintenance tickets, your best choice is a SemperScreen® permanent sink screen (more below, or, to read about how the options differ, start with what a sink screen is).

A common practical challenge is the elevation difference between where the old disposal outlet sat and where the new P-trap connection point needs to be. Disposals are bulky units that position their drain outlet lower than a standard P-trap assembly typically sits. As Family Handyman notes, a discharge tube that is too long gets trimmed to length, and one that is too short gets replaced [5]. A licensed plumber handles this measurement and fitting as a routine part of the conversion.

For double sinks, the new plumbing simply replaces the disposal's outlet position with a standard tailpiece connecting to the shared P-trap, a familiar configuration that plumbers complete routinely.

Step-by-Step: The Conversion Process

Step 1: Disconnect the Power

If the disposal plugs into an outlet under the sink, unplug it. If it's hardwired, switch off its breaker, then check the wires with a non-contact voltage tester before you touch anything. Once the unit is off the sink, cap the wires with wire nuts inside a covered electrical box, or have an electrician remove the circuit.

Step 2: Disconnect the Dishwasher Drain (If Present)

The dishwasher hose clamps onto a small inlet on the side of the disposal. Loosen the clamp with a screwdriver, pull the hose off, and hang the end higher than the sink so it doesn't drip while you work.

Step 3: Disconnect the Drain Lines

Put the bucket under the trap. Loosen the slip nuts on the disposal's discharge tube and on the trap by hand or with pliers. Water that was sitting in the trap will drain into the bucket.

Step 4: Unmount and Remove the Disposal

The disposal hangs from a mounting ring under the sink. Turn that ring counterclockwise and the unit drops free, so hold it from below while you turn, because it's heavier than it looks. Then remove the mounting assembly and the old sink flange from above, and scrape every bit of old putty off the sink opening until it's clean and dry.

Step 5: Install the New Drain Screen

Roll a rope of plumber's putty and press it under the rim of the new drain. Set the drain in the opening from above and press it down. From below, add the gasket and the nut and tighten them until the drain no longer turns. Don't overtighten, especially on a porcelain or composite sink. Wipe away the putty that squeezes out on top.

If you're fitting a SemperScreen®, it replaces the whole drain assembly (flange, screen, gasket and tailpiece connection) in one part. Our installation instructions walk through it, and how it works shows how the parts fit together.

Step 6: Reconnect the Drain Plumbing

Connect the tailpiece from the new drain down to the trap, then the trap to the wall outlet. Dry-fit everything first. If the tailpiece is too long, cut it square; if it's too short, add an extension. Each slip joint needs its washer facing the right way and a nut that's snug, not cranked.

Step 7: Reconnect the Dishwasher

A plain basket strainer has no inlet for the dishwasher hose, so the hose moves to a branch tailpiece, a tailpiece with a side inlet that sits between the drain and the trap. The rule that matters is backflow: dirty sink water must never be able to run back into the dishwasher. The International Plumbing Code lets the hose connect to a sink tailpiece either through a countertop air gap or by running the hose up and fastening it to the underside of the counter or sink rim before it drops to the tailpiece (Section 802.1.6 in the 2015 edition) [6]. Some states and cities require the countertop air gap. Check your local code, or ask your plumber which one applies.

Step 8: Test for Leaks

Plug the sink, fill it a few inches deep, then pull the plug and watch every joint underneath with a dry paper towel. A damp towel finds a slow drip faster than your eyes do. Run the faucet hard for a few minutes and check again. If you have a dishwasher, run a full cycle and check the hose connection during the drain.

How much does it cost to remove a garbage disposal and install a regular drain?

The bill has three parts:

  • The new drain. A basic basket strainer is the cheapest piece in the job. A permanent screen costs more up front because it replaces the whole drain assembly in one part.
  • Pipe and fittings. A tailpiece, an extension or new trap if the height changed, and a branch tailpiece if there's a dishwasher.
  • Labor, if you hire it. One visit for a plumber in most kitchens. A hardwired disposal can add an electrician, and a double sink or a tight cabinet adds time.

Plumber rates vary by city, so get a quote that lists those three items separately. Then compare it with what the disposal is already costing you. Our own figure for a typical plumbing service call is $250+ per call. Count how many calls your disposal sink has needed in the last few years and put that next to the quote.

The Better Upgrade: SemperScreen® Permanent Sink Screen

A basket strainer only protects the drain while it's in the sink. In a home where one careful person does the dishes, that can be fine. In a rental, a shared kitchen or an office breakroom, someone lifts it out to drain a pot and it doesn't go back. That's why a major retailer with 1,900+ stores and distribution centers moved its breakroom sinks to SemperScreen®: an 8-store pilot became its company renovation standard, rollout through 2027/2028, with 60+ locations supplied and counting. By our numbers, the switch saves the retailer "thousands of dollars" per install.

The SemperScreen® permanent sink screen fits standard 3½-inch kitchen drains, the same opening your disposal used. The screen is part of the drain body, so there's nothing to lift out and nothing to lose. Food stops on top of the screen, where you scoop it into the trash or compost, and water keeps flowing through. It's polished 304 stainless steel with no moving parts.

On a sink with a working drain, the install is ~15 minutes per drain, retrofit, no plumbing modifications. After a disposal removal you'll be setting the tailpiece and trap anyway (Step 6), so it goes in during the same visit. Because the screen stays put, filling the basin takes a stopper made to sit on it: the SemperStopper™.

It's certified to ASME A112.18.2 / CSA B125.2, carries a lifetime residential, 5-year commercial warranty, and there are 20,000+ sold since 2017. Questions about fit are answered in the FAQs. If you're converting a building full of units, see pricing for properties and facilities.

SemperScreen® recommends that you always refer to local building codes when modifying a building's plumbing system.

References

  1. International Code Council. International Plumbing Code, Section 422.2 Sink waste outlets (2018, 2021 and 2024 editions; Section 418.2 in the 2015 edition).
  2. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. "How to Care for Your Septic System." epa.gov/septic/how-care-your-septic-system
  3. Lowe's. "How to Install a Garbage Disposal." lowes.com/n/how-to/install-a-garbage-disposal
  4. Apartments.com Rental Manager. "Should I Install a Garbage Disposal in My Rental?" apartments.com/rental-manager/resources
  5. Family Handyman. "A Step-by-Step Guide to Installing and Replacing a Garbage Disposal." familyhandyman.com/project/how-to-replace-a-garbage-disposal
  6. International Code Council. International Plumbing Code 2015, Section 802.1.6 Domestic dishwashing machines.